A Small Cut for a Stronger Start: Pruning Shallot Seedlings Before the Field

For many shallot farmers, good production begins with good planting material. Traditionally, shallots are grown from bulbs, but this method requires a large amount of planting material and may carry diseases from one season to the next. True shallot seed offers a promising alternative because it needs less planting material, is easier to transport, and can produce healthier crops. However, seed-grown shallots also bring a challenge: seedlings need a nursery period before transplanting, and weak seedlings may not survive well in the field.

A study published in the Journal of Agriculture Faculty of Ege University investigated a simple question: can pruning improve the growth of shallot seedlings grown from seeds? The researchers tested three shallot varieties, Sanren F1, Lokananta, and Maserati, and compared three pruning frequencies. Seedlings were pruned once at 25 days after sowing, twice at 25 and 30 days, or three times at 25, 30, and 35 days. The pruning method was simple: about 25% of the leaf length was cut in the morning using scissors.

The results showed that pruning mattered. Seedlings pruned three times had better growth than those pruned once or twice. They produced more leaves, thicker pseudostems, longer roots, more root tips, and higher fresh and dry seedling weight. In practical terms, repeated pruning helped seedlings become stronger both above and below the soil surface.

The response also depended on the variety. Maserati produced the highest number of leaves and root tips. Lokananta had the largest pseudostem diameter and the heaviest fresh and dry seedling weight. Sanren F1 produced the longest roots. These differences show that genetics still play an important role, but pruning can improve seedling performance across varieties.

Why can cutting leaves make seedlings stronger? Pruning may encourage new leaf growth and help balance the relationship between shoots and roots. When seedlings have better root development, they may absorb water and nutrients more effectively after transplanting. A thicker pseudostem may also help seedlings become more robust before they are moved to the field.

This research supports Sustainable Development Goal 1: No Poverty. For smallholder farmers, stronger seedlings can mean fewer losses after transplanting, better crop establishment, and more reliable production. A simple nursery practice such as scheduled pruning does not require expensive equipment, making it suitable for practical use by farmers and seedling producers.

The main message is clear: sometimes a small cut can lead to stronger growth. By pruning shallot seedlings three times during the nursery period, farmers may produce healthier seedlings that are better prepared for field conditions. Better seedlings can become the first step toward better harvests and more stable farmer livelihoods.