Why Islamic Banking Still Struggles to Grow: A Human Psychology Perspective

In recent years, Islamic banking has gained global attention as an ethical and inclusive financial alternative. However, despite its promising values and steady development, its market share in countries with dual-banking systems remains relatively stagnant. Why does this happen? The answer may not lie solely in economics or regulation—but in the way people think.

A study titled “Stagnant Islamic Banking Market Share in Dual-Banking System: Insights from Cognitive Psychology Study of Representativeness and Anchoring-Adjustment Heuristics”, published in the Journal of Islamic Marketing by Emerald on 26 January 2026, explores this issue from a fresh angle. Instead of focusing only on financial structures, the study highlights how cognitive biases influence people’s banking choices.

The research explains two key psychological concepts: representativeness and anchoring-adjustment heuristics. Representativeness refers to how individuals judge something based on how closely it matches their existing perceptions or stereotypes. Many people still associate Islamic banking with limited services or religious exclusivity, even when this is no longer accurate. As a result, they may overlook its real benefits.

Meanwhile, anchoring-adjustment heuristic shows how people rely heavily on their initial impressions. If someone first learned about Islamic banking as being less competitive or less accessible, that “anchor” can shape their perception for years—even when conditions improve. These mental shortcuts, while useful in everyday decision-making, can unintentionally slow down the adoption of better financial options.

This issue is particularly important when viewed through the lens of SDG 4: Quality Education. Financial literacy is a crucial part of modern education, yet many people lack a clear understanding of how Islamic banking works. By improving public knowledge and awareness, societies can empower individuals to make more informed financial decisions. Education can help break outdated stereotypes and correct misconceptions rooted in cognitive bias.

Moreover, better communication strategies are needed. Islamic banking institutions must go beyond traditional marketing and adopt more engaging, relatable messaging that addresses public perceptions directly. Storytelling, digital campaigns, and community outreach can play a major role in reshaping how people view these financial services.

The study ultimately reminds us that economic growth is not just about systems and policies—it is also about human behavior. Even the most well-designed financial products can struggle if people’s perceptions do not evolve alongside them.

In conclusion, the stagnation of Islamic banking market share is not merely a financial issue, but a psychological one. By addressing cognitive biases and strengthening financial education in line with SDG 4, there is a strong opportunity to unlock its full potential. Understanding how people think may be the key to transforming how they choose—and ultimately, how inclusive financial systems can grow.

Abdul Hamid Habbe

0811469002

https://doi.org/10.1108/JIMA-05-2025-0286