When Knowledge Meets Behavior: Why Nutrition Education Alone Is Not Enough to Change Adolescent Eating Habits in Remote Islands

Tanakeke Islands, South Sulawesi, May 23 2025/MC-Nutrition/-Adolescence is a critical time for growth. During this period, girls need enough energy, protein, vitamins, minerals, fruits, and vegetables to support their bodies, learning ability, and future health. However, in many remote and island communities, healthy food choices are not always easy to access or practiced every day. Limited nutrition knowledge, family habits, and local food availability can influence what adolescents eat.

A published article entitled “Effects of Nutrition Education Based on Social Cognitive Theory on Fruit and Vegetable Consumption Among Adolescent Girls in Tanakeke Islands, South Sulawesi” provides important evidence on this issue. The article was published in the Malaysian Journal of Medical Sciences, Volume 32, Issue 4, pages 224–235, in 2025, by Penerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia, with DOI 10.21315/mjms-01-2025-014. The article was submitted on 10 March 2025, accepted on 23 May 2025, and published online on 30 August 2025.

The study focused on undernourished adolescent girls living in the Tanakeke Islands, Takalar Regency, South Sulawesi. This area represents a remote island setting where nutrition challenges can be influenced by geography, household income, food access, and education. The research used a quasi-experimental design involving four schools. A total of 88 adolescent girls completed the study after 12 weeks.

The intervention group received nutrition education based on Social Cognitive Theory. This approach does not only teach facts about healthy food. It also helps students build motivation, understand the benefits of eating better, regulate their own behavior, and receive support from their environment. The education program included role-playing, student modules, interactive sessions, and monthly education for parents. Meanwhile, the control group received nutrition leaflets from the Ministry of Health.

The results were encouraging. After 12 weeks, the intervention group showed improvements in nutrition knowledge, outcome expectations, self Adolescent nutrition is often seen as a matter of knowledge—if teenagers know what is healthy, they will eat better. However, reality in many remote Indonesian islands shows a different picture. Even when nutrition information is provided, actual dietary behavior, especially fruit and vegetable consumption, remains far below recommended levels. This gap between knowledge and behavior raises an important question: what truly drives adolescents to change what they eat?

This scientific article titled “Effects of Nutrition Education Based on Social Cognitive Theory on Fruit and Vegetable Consumption Among Adolescent Girls in Tanakeke Islands, South Sulawesi” was published in the Malaysian Journal of Medical Sciences in 2025 (Vol. 32, Issue 4, pp. 224–235). The study was conducted by Firdaus et al., including Prof. Veni Hadju, and involved adolescent girls from undernourished populations in the Tanakeke Islands, South Sulawesi, Indonesia .

The research aimed to evaluate how nutrition education based on Social Cognitive Theory (SCT) influences knowledge, psychological constructs, and fruit and vegetable intake among adolescent girls living in resource-limited island settings. A total of 88 participants were involved in a quasi-experimental study with intervention and control groups over a 12-week period .

When Knowledge Alone Is Not Enough

The study began with a key observation: although adolescents were exposed to nutrition education, their baseline fruit and vegetable intake remained extremely low. This reflects a common challenge in public health nutrition—information does not automatically translate into behavior.

In the SCT framework, behavior is influenced not only by knowledge but also by self-efficacy, outcome expectations, self-regulation, and environmental support. These psychological and social factors determine whether adolescents can realistically apply what they learn in daily life.

How the Intervention Was Designed

The intervention group received a 12-week structured nutrition education program based on SCT principles. The program included interactive learning sessions, role-playing, parental involvement sessions, and self-monitoring activities. Students were also given learning modules to reinforce behavior outside classroom settings.

The control group received standard leaflet-based nutrition education from health authorities, without structured behavioral reinforcement or parental engagement .

Why Self-Efficacy Matters More Than Information

One of the most important findings of the study is the weak improvement in self-efficacy. Within SCT, self-efficacy is a core determinant of behavior change because it reflects a person’s confidence in performing a specific action.

Without strong self-efficacy, adolescents may understand what to do but still fail to act consistently. This explains why knowledge gains did not fully translate into large dietary behavior changes.

Alignment with Sustainable Development Goals

This study strongly contributes to:

  • SDG 2: Zero Hunger, by addressing adolescent undernutrition and poor dietary diversity
  • SDG 3: Good Health and Well-being, through prevention of long-term nutrition-related health risks
  • SDG 4: Quality Education, by integrating behavioral learning into school-based nutrition programs
  • SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals, through collaboration between universities, schools, parents, and communities

Reference : 

DOI 10.21315/mjms-01-2025-014.

Contact :

Prof. dr. Veni Hadju, M.Sc., Ph. D

+62811441803

phunhas@gmail.com