Jakarta, Indonesia, 2025/MC-Nutrition/-Why do patients still feel dissatisfied even when hospitals are well-equipped and medically competent? Is the problem always about medical quality, or is there something deeper hidden in how healthcare services are delivered and perceived?
These questions are explored in a multicenter study titled “Assessment of Strategic Healthcare Development Using Importance-Performance Analysis: A Multicenter Study of Three Sharia Hospitals in Indonesia,” published in Health Leadership and Quality of Life (2025, Vol. 4:714, DOI: 10.56294/hl2025714). The study analyzed patient perceptions across three Sharia hospitals in Indonesia, YARSI Hospital Jakarta, Sari Asih Hospital Serang, and Annisa Hospital Cikarang Bekasi to evaluate gaps between service importance and actual performance using the Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) framework .
The study involved 382 inpatients using a structured questionnaire assessing five key service dimensions: responsiveness, assurance, empathy, tangibles, and reliability. Data were analyzed using IPA mapping, categorizing hospital service attributes into four quadrants based on patient expectations and perceived performance .
When Expectations Are Higher Than Reality
Across all three hospitals, a consistent pattern emerged: patient expectations were higher than perceived service performance. The overall analysis showed an average performance score of 3.713 and an importance score of 3.839, indicating a persistent service gap in Sharia hospital care delivery .
The Critical Weak Points in Hospital Service
The IPA results revealed several service attributes placed in the “Concentrate Here” quadrant—meaning they are highly important but underperforming. These include clarity of information, responsiveness of staff, patient education, and aspects of safety and service coordination. Patients consistently rated these dimensions as essential, yet their actual experiences did not meet expectations.
In healthcare systems, these elements are not secondary they shape trust, satisfaction, and adherence to treatment. When communication is unclear or responsiveness is delayed, even high-quality clinical care may feel inadequate to patients
What Hospitals Are Doing Well
At the same time, several service dimensions performed strongly and matched patient expectations. These include medical ethics, staff professionalism, hospital access, and care coordination. These strengths indicate that foundational hospital systems are functioning well and should be maintained to preserve service quality.
However, IPA also identified areas of “possible overkill,” where performance is high but importance is relatively low. These areas suggest potential inefficiencies in resource allocation.
Beyond Medicine: A Service Strategy Problem
The study highlights an important insight: improving hospital performance is not only about increasing medical capacity, but also about aligning service delivery with patient expectations. Importance-Performance Analysis provides a strategic tool for identifying where hospitals should prioritize improvement efforts.
By focusing on high-importance but low-performance areas, hospital administrators can make targeted interventions that directly improve patient satisfaction and service quality.
Toward Patient-Centered Sharia Healthcare
This research contributes to SDG 3: Good Health and Well-being, by improving healthcare quality and patient safety. It also supports SDG 16: Strong Institutions, by strengthening hospital governance and service accountability. Furthermore, it aligns with SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals, through collaboration between academic institutions and healthcare providers.
DOI Referensi
: https://doi.org/10.56294/hl2025714
Kontak:
Prof.dr. Veni Hadju, M.Sc., Ph.D
+62811441803
