In today’s fast-moving economy, banks play a crucial role in shaping how people save, invest, and grow their businesses. But how efficient are these banks in managing money and supporting economic development? A recent study titled “Efficiency of the Banking Sector in Indonesia, Conventional and Islamic: A Stochastic Frontier Analysis” provides important insights into this question and highlights why efficiency matters for a better future.
Published in the International Journal of Innovative Research and Scientific Studies (Vol. 8(2), 2025, pages 4594–4604) by Innovative Research Publishing, the study examines how well conventional and Islamic banks in Indonesia perform between 2021 and mid-2024. Using advanced analysis methods, the researchers found that conventional banks tend to be more stable and consistently efficient. Meanwhile, Islamic banks show more fluctuation but are steadily improving—especially in 2024.
So why does this matter to everyday people?
Efficient banks can manage funds better, reduce costs, and provide more reliable financial services. This directly affects access to loans, savings opportunities, and financial security. In simpler terms, when banks work efficiently, communities benefit. Businesses can grow, jobs can be created, and individuals can better plan their financial future.
One interesting finding from the study is the role of “third-party funds” (money deposited by customers). While these funds are essential, poor management can actually reduce bank profitability due to higher operational costs and risks. On the other hand, smart liquidity management—such as placing funds in central banks or financing productive activities—can significantly improve performance.
Islamic banks, in particular, offer a unique perspective. Unlike conventional banks, they follow ethical principles such as profit-sharing and avoiding interest. This makes them attractive to customers who value fairness and social responsibility. However, these same principles can limit flexibility, making efficiency harder to achieve. The good news is that technological innovation and better financial strategies are helping Islamic banks catch up.
This discussion connects strongly with SDG 8: Decent Work and Economic Growth. Efficient banking systems support sustainable economic growth by improving access to finance, encouraging entrepreneurship, and strengthening financial stability. When banks perform well, they become powerful tools for reducing inequality and promoting inclusive development.
The study also highlights an important takeaway for policymakers: both banking systems have strengths. Conventional banks excel in stability and scale, while Islamic banks bring ethical value and social impact. Instead of viewing them as competitors, there is potential for synergy—combining efficiency with ethical finance to create a more balanced financial ecosystem.
In conclusion, banking efficiency is not just a technical issue—it affects real lives. As Indonesia continues to grow, improving the performance of both conventional and Islamic banks will be key to building a stronger, more inclusive economy.
Abdul Hamid Habbe
0811469002


