Beyond Written Promises: Why Indonesia Must Bring Victim Protection into the Heart of Justice

MAKASSAR, Indonesia 23 juli 2026/VICTORY/- A criminal justice system is often judged by how effectively it investigates crime and punishes offenders. Yet justice is incomplete when witnesses are intimidated, victims are retraumatized, and the institutions responsible for protecting them remain outside the main structure of criminal procedure. In Indonesia, this problem has become increasingly urgent as reform of the Criminal Procedure Code promises stronger protection but may still leave serious gaps in practice.

This popular article is adapted from the peer-reviewed academic article “The Integration of the LPSK into the Criminal Justice System: The Urgency of Witness and Victim Protection Amidst an Illusion of Criminal Procedure Law Reform.” Written by Robbi Fathan, Syarif Saddam Rivanie, Muhammad Said Karim, Ismail Iskandar, Sriyana, and Hamzah Halim, it was published in SIGn Journal of Social Science, Volume 6, Issue 1, pages 69–87. The journal is published by CV Social Politic Genius (SIGn), and the article was published online on October 20, 2025.
The study highlights a basic imbalance in Indonesia’s current criminal procedure law. Law Number 8 of 1981 provides detailed rights for suspects and defendants, but the rights of witnesses and victims are scattered and limited. Victims are frequently treated mainly as sources of evidence rather than as people who need protection, recovery, information, restitution, and meaningful participation. This can create secondary victimization, where interaction with the justice system adds new suffering to the harm already caused by the crime.

The proposed Criminal Procedure Code Bill appears more progressive because it lists various rights for witnesses and victims. However, the researchers warn that these promises may become an “illusion of protection.” The Bill refers protection to the institution responsible for witnesses and victims but does not clearly require investigators, prosecutors, and judges to coordinate with the Witness and Victim Protection Agency, known as LPSK. Rights written on paper may therefore remain difficult to access.

The study shows that LPSK has already played a decisive role in major cases. Its protection, credibility assessments, and recommendations regarding justice collaborators can help uncover complex crimes and support fairer decisions. Nevertheless, LPSK often faces institutional resistance, overlapping authority, limited public understanding, and weak coordination with other law-enforcement bodies.

The authors propose two solutions. First, the Criminal Procedure Code Bill should expressly place LPSK within the criminal justice system and require binding coordination among LPSK, police, prosecutors, courts, advocates, and correctional institutions. Second, Law Number 13 of 2006 should be strengthened as a special law, giving LPSK clearer authority and stronger emergency protection powers.

This reform is closely connected to SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals. Effective witness and victim protection cannot be delivered by one institution alone. It requires structured cooperation among government agencies, legal professionals, civil society, universities, and communities. Integrating LPSK is therefore not merely an institutional adjustment. It is a step toward a justice system that listens, protects, restores, and ensures that victims are no longer left at the edge of the legal process.

Reference:

DOI : 10.37276/sjss.v6i1.517.

Contact :
Dr. Nur Azisa
+62 896-5492-8727
nur.azisa@unhas.ac.id