Bridging the Welfare Gap: Why Location Still Matters in Social Assistance

Why do some communities benefit more from government welfare programs than others? A newly published study in Indonesia suggests that where people live—whether in peri-urban or rural areas—can strongly influence how they experience social welfare support.

The article titled “Comparative Study of Social Welfare Programme Effectiveness Perception in Peri-Urban and Rural in Indonesia” was published in the Asia Pacific Journal of Social Work and Development, issued by Taylor and Francis Online, on 14 April 2026. The study explores how residents in different regions perceive the success of welfare programs designed to reduce poverty and improve quality of life.

Social welfare programs are meant to help vulnerable citizens meet basic needs such as food, healthcare, education, and income security. However, this research found that perceptions of program effectiveness vary significantly between peri-urban and rural communities. Peri-urban areas—regions located between cities and villages—often have better roads, stronger internet access, and closer connections to government services. Because of this, residents may find it easier to receive information, complete registration, and access benefits.

Meanwhile, rural communities frequently face greater challenges. Long travel distances, limited transportation, lower digital connectivity, and fewer service centers can make welfare assistance harder to reach. Even when programs exist, barriers in access may reduce their real impact. As a result, many rural residents feel that social protection policies do not fully meet their daily needs.

This issue is directly connected to SDG 1: No Poverty. Ending poverty is not only about creating programs—it is about ensuring those programs reach everyone fairly. If people in remote areas cannot access support, poverty gaps may continue to grow. Effective welfare systems must be inclusive, responsive, and sensitive to local realities.

The findings also show that community trust matters. When people believe a program is transparent, fair, and easy to access, they are more likely to participate and support government initiatives. On the other hand, complicated procedures or unclear targeting can create frustration and reduce confidence in public institutions.

For policymakers, the message is clear: one national policy may not work equally in every region. Governments need more flexible approaches that recognize local differences. In peri-urban areas, digital systems may improve efficiency. In rural areas, mobile services, village-based facilitators, and stronger outreach may be more effective.

Indonesia has made major progress in expanding social protection, but this study reminds us that development is not only about numbers. It is also about people’s lived experiences. Success should be measured not just by how many receive benefits, but by whether those benefits truly improve lives.

Reducing poverty requires listening to communities, adapting services, and ensuring no one is left behind because of geography. When welfare programs work for both peri-urban and rural citizens, social justice becomes more than a promise—it becomes reality.


Reference:

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/29949769.2024.2342794

Contact:
Prof. Nurlinah
+62 812-4249-867
nurlinah@unhas.ac.id

or

Muhammad Chaeroel Ansar
+62 852-4221-2842
mchaeroel@unhas.ac.id